GOALTENDERS - DEFENSEMEN - LEFT WINGS - RIGHT WINGS - CENTERS - BACK TO MAIN PAGE

 

  • Player rankings are based on standard rotisserie rankings using expected production for the rest of the year.
  • Skaters evaluated based on goals, assists, plus/minus ratio, penalty minutes, power play points, game winning goals.
  • Goaltenders are ranked based on expected wins, goals against average, save percentage, and shutouts.
  • The overall rankings were compiled using the averages of the contributing hockey moderators.
Updated September 12, 2006

Rank
Defensemen
Team
RotoKing
Sergeant Wolfe
Tri State Titan
Average
1.
Nicklas Lidstrom
DET
1
1
1
1.00
2.
Chris Pronger
ANA
2
2
4
2.67
3.
Bryan McCabe
TOR
4
6
3
4.33
4.
Wade Redden
OTT
5
3
8
5.33
5.
Sergei Gonchar
PIT
7
10
2
6.33
6.
Scott Niedermayer
ANA
3
5
11
6.33
7.
Sergei Zubov
DAL
10
8
5
7.67
8.
Dion Phaneuf
CGY
14
4
7
8.33
9.
Mathieu Schneider
DET
6
9
12
9.00
10.
Zdeno Chara
BOS
8
7
16
10.33
11.
Marek Zidlicky
NSH
9
18
6
11.00
12.
Rob Blake
LA
11
11
13
11.67
13.
Tomas Kaberle
TOR
15
15
9
13.00
14.
Dan Boyle
TB
12
12
17
13.67
15.
Lubomir Visnovsky
LA
16
13
14
14.33
16.
Joni Pitkanen
PHI
13
16
18
15.67
17.
Andrei Markov
MON
21
20
21
20.67
18.
Kimmo Timonen
NSH
18
24
24
22.00
19.
Ed Jovanovski
PHO
17
35
19
23.67
20.
John-Michael Liles
COL 
19
26
27
24.00
21.
Paul Mara
BOS
26
36
15
25.67
22.
Joe Corvo
OTT
34
25
22
27.00
23.
Jaroslav Spacek
BUF
27
22
32
27.00
24.
Brian Rafalski
NJ
22
30
30
27.33
25.
Tom Preissing
OTT
33
21
33
29.00
26.
Bryan Berard
CLB
20
51
20
30.33
27.
Sheldon Souray
MON
25
37
31
31.00
28.
Andrej Meszaros
OTT
40
17
37
31.33
29.
Brian Campbell
BUF
37
32
29
32.67
30.
Kim Johnsson
MIN
24
51
26
33.67
31.
Mike Van Ryn
FLA 
32
27
42
33.67
32.
Jay Bouwmeester
FLA 
42
51
10
34.33
33.
Philippe Boucher
DAL
23
19
61
34.33
34.
Brian Pothier
WAS
48
34
23
35.00
35.
Mattias Ohlund
VAN
29
51
35
38.33
36.
Frantisek Kaberle
CAR
46
23
47
38.67
37.
Roman Hamrlik
CGY
28
51
40
39.67
38.
Jaroslav Modry
DAL
38
33
49
40.00
39.
Brian Leetch
FA
36
51
34
40.33
40.
Dan Hamhuis
NSH
53
29
41
41.00
41.
Derek Morris
PHX
39
51
36
42.00
42.
Brad Stuart
BOS
30
41
59
43.33
43.
Matthew Carle
SJ
52
51
28
43.67
44.
Pavel Kubina
TOR
31
28
75
44.67
45.
Chris Campoli
NYI
59
51
25
45.00
46.
Sandis Ozolinsh
NYR
35
51
50
45.33
47.
Marc-Andre Bergeron
EDM
43
51
43
45.67
48.
Adrian Aucoin
CHI
41
51
45
45.67
49.
Jordan Leopold
COL 
45
49
46
46.67
50.
Paul Martin
NJ
58
51
39
49.33
51.
Steve Staios
EDM
47
51
51
49.67
52.
Andy Sutton
ATL
62
31
56
49.67
53.
Marek Malik
NYR
64
14
74
50.67
54.
Dick Tarnstrom
EDM
49
51
54
51.33
55.
Tom Poti
NYI
50
40
65
51.67
56.
Sami Salo
VAN
54
51
52
52.33
57.
Francois Beauchemin
ANA
63
39
57
53.00
58.
Nick Boynton
PHX
44
51
66
53.67
59.
Brent Seabrook
CHI
68
51
44
54.33
60.
Alexei Zhitnik
NYI
60
51
53
54.67
61.
Patrice Brisebois
COL 
55
42
69
55.33
62.
Dennis Wideman
STL
70
51
48
56.33
63.
Ryan Whitney
PIT
81
51
38
56.67
64.
Nolan Baumgartner
PHI
66
44
63
57.67
65.
Teppo Numminen
BUF
69
51
55
58.33
66.
Greg de Vries
ATL
72
38
68
59.33
67.
Dmitri Kalinin
BUF
51
51
81
61.00
68.
Andreas Lilja
DET
76
51
58
61.67
69.
Brent Sopel
LA
56
51
79
62.00
70.
Michal Rozsival
NYR
78
51
60
63.00
71.
Adam Foote
CLB
57
51
81
63.00
72.
Eric Brewer
STL
71
51
71
64.33
73.
Sean Hill
NYI
61
51
81
64.33
74.
Steve McCarthy
ATL
81
51
62
64.67
75.
Jamie Heward
WAS
81
51
64
65.33
76.
Janne Niinimaa
DAL
65
51
81
65.67
77.
Christian Ehrhoff
SJ
81
51
67
66.33
78.
Ric Jackman
FLA 
67
51
81
66.33
79.
Karel Rachunek
NYR
81
51
70
67.33
80.
Andy Delmore
TB
81
51
72
68.00

 

Other Players Receiving Votes:
Mike Rathje, Oleg Tverdovsky, Robyn Regehr, Craig Rivet, Niclas Havelid, Ruslan Salei, Paul Mara, Willie Mitchell, Chris Chelios,
Danny Markov, Keith Ballard, Brendan Witt, Jason Smith, Rhett Warrener, Eric Desjardins